Bakery Menu | Miss Lilly’s Newtown Sydney

Our savoury pies are baked and chilled, ready to reheat at home.

Cakes and sweets are made to order so we need 24 hours lead time from confirmation of the order.

Let us know the pickup time and date in the Additional information box on the checkout page.

Special Canape Picnic Set

Perfect for Two: The Ultimate Picnic Set

Elevate your picnic with our thoughtfully curated set, made to serve two. This selection includes four canapé pies, four canapé sausage rolls, four canapé quiches, and four canapé sweets, with two flavor options for each. Wherever you spread your blanket—park, beach, or beyond—this set makes it deliciously easy.

******Important Notice****** Please make sure to select two flavors for each type and specify them in the “Special Notes” section before submitting your order.

**Pie: Steak Mushroom / Chicken Leek Mustard / Beef Jalapeno Cheese / Classic Beef

**Sausage Roll: Kale Feta / Pork Fennel / Lamb Roast Garlic / Beef Herb

**Quiche: Ham cheddar / Salmon Ricotta / Pumpkin Feta

**Sweet: Lemon tart / Brownie / Caramel Slice

$40.00 inc GST

Cake

Lemon curd cake

Classic lemon butter cake with yoghurt and ground almonds, drizzled with lemon syrup and filled and topped with lemon curd.

$40.00 – $120.00 inc GST

Chai-spiced carrot cake

Chai spiced carrot cake, flavoured with chai tea and finished with lemon cream cheese icing, topped with pepita, sunflower and poppy seeds

$40.00 – $120.00 inc GST

Chocolate hazelnut cake (Gluten free)

Rich and moist flourless hazelnut chocolate cake topped with dark chocolate nutella ganache.

$40.00 – $70.00 inc GST

Orange almond syrup cake (Gluten free)

Tunisian almond meal based orange cake topped with oranges glazed in a cinnamon and star anise syrup.

Dairy free.

$35.00 – $60.00 inc GST

Chocolate “Your Message Here” plaque

Just write in the notes section on checkout exactly what you would like the message to say and we will write it on a chocolate plaque and place on the cake for you!

$5.00 inc GST

Passionfruit cheesecake

Classic baked cheese cake topped with a housemade passion gel (gelatine free!)

$70.00 inc GST

Pistachio raspberry cake

Pistachio almond cake filled with raspberry jam, topped with sweet pistachio icing and freeze dried raspberries.

$35.00 – $60.00 inc GST

~Christmas Special~ Pavlova

Christmas Special House-made Pavlova topped with seasonal fruits

$65.00 inc GST

~Christmas Special~ Naked Pavlova

Christmas Special House-made Naked Pavlova Top it with your favorite topping

$25.00 inc GST

Individual Quiche

Pumpkin Feta and Shallot

Roasted pumpkin, feta and shallots with cheddar cheese with a light creamy custard in short pastry.

$8.50 inc GST

Ham and Cheddar

Slow cooked shredded ham hock with shallots, cheddar cheese with a light creamy custard in short pastry.

$8.50 inc GST

Smoked Salmon Ricotta and Dill

Smoked salmon and ricotta with shallots, cheddar cheese and dill with a light creamy custard in short pastry.

$8.50 inc GST

Individual Pies

Beef & mushroom

Chunky Cape Grim beef slow cooked with onion, celery, garlic, thyme, black pepper and button mushrooms in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$9.50 inc GST

Classic beef mince

Cape Grim beef mince with onion, thyme, garlic and tomato paste cooked in our own free range chicken stock in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$9.50 inc GST

Beef, jalapeno & cheddar

Our classic beef mince pie topped with a spicy jalapeno cheese sauce in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$9.50 inc GST

Chicken leek & mustard

Poached Free Range chicken with sauteed leeks, celery and onion, fresh parsley and wholegrain mustard in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$9.50 inc GST

Lamb shepherds

Lamb mince, white wine and rosemary with carrot, onion, peas and Worcestershire sauce in a shortcrust base topped with buttery potato puree.

$9.50 inc GST

Pumpkin, lentil & harissa (vegan)

Red capsicum with tomato, Australian lentils and our own harissa spice blend finished with roasted butternut pumpkin and coriander in a vegan short pastry.

$9.50 inc GST

Eggplant, pea & potato curry (vegan)

Eggplant cooked in a tomato based Sri Lankan style curry with potato, peas and coriander in a vegan short pastry.

$9.50 inc GST

Mushroom bolognese with cashew cheese (vegan)

Two types of mushrooms with Australian lentils in a traditional bolognese style sauce topped with our own cashew cheese sauce in a vegan shortcrust pastry.

$9.50 inc GST

Sausage Rolls

Pork & fennel

Free range pork with celery, onion, fennel seeds and fresh parsley, rolled in puff pastry.

$8.00 inc GST

Beef & herb

Cape Grim beef with grated carrot, onion, oregano, chopped parsley and tomato paste rolled in puff pastry.

$8.00 inc GST

Lamb & roast garlic

Lamb mince with roasted garlic cloves smashed through, grated carrot, onion, and rosemary rolled in puff pastry.

$8.00 inc GST

Kale & feta

A mix of kale and spinach with feta, ricotta, parmesan, onion, lemon, and fresh parsley, rolled in puff pastry.

$8.00 inc GST

Pastries

Croissant

$6.00 inc GST

Pain au chocolat (chocolate croissant)

$7.00 inc GST

Family Pies

Family Eggplant, pea, potato curry (vegan)

Eggplant cooked in a tomato based Sri Lankan style curry with potato, peas and coriander in a vegan short pastry.

$35.00 inc GST

Family Pumpkin, lentil & harissa (vegan)

Red capsicum with tomato, Australian lentils and our own harissa spice blend finished with roasted butternut pumpkin and coriander in a vegan short pastry.

$35.00 inc GST

Family Lamb shepherds

Lamb mince, white wine and rosemary with carrot, onion, peas and Worcestershire sauce in a shortcrust base topped with buttery potato puree.

$35.00 inc GST

Family Chicken leek & mustard

Poached Free Range chicken with sauteed leeks, celery and onion, fresh parsley and wholegrain mustard in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$35.00 inc GST

Family Beef, jalapeno & cheddar

Our classic beef mince pie topped with a spicy jalapeno cheese sauce in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$35.00 inc GST

Family Classic beef mince

Cape Grim beef mince with onion, thyme, garlic and tomato paste cooked in our own free range chicken stock in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$35.00 inc GST

Family Beef & mushroom

Chunky Cape Grim beef slow cooked with onion, celery, garlic, thyme, black pepper and button mushrooms in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$35.00 inc GST

Family Mushroom bolognese with cashew cheese (vegan)

Two types of mushrooms with Australian lentils in a traditional bolognese style sauce topped with our own cashew cheese sauce in a vegan shortcrust pastry.

$35.00 inc GST

Family Quiche

Family Roast pumpkin, feta & shallot

Roasted pumpkin, feta and shallots with cheddar cheese with a light creamy custard in short pastry.

$36.00 inc GST

Family Smoked salmon, ricotta & dill

Smoked salmon and ricotta with shallots, cheddar cheese and dill with a light creamy custard in short pastry.

$36.00 inc GST

Family ham and cheddar

Slow cooked shredded ham hock with shallots, cheddar cheese with a light creamy custard in short pastry.

$36.00 inc GST

Sweet Pie

Apple pie

Granny Smith apple and cinnamon in our sour cream shortcrust.

$36.00 inc GST

Sour cherry Pie

Sour cherries and cinnamon in our sour cream shortcrust pastry.

$36.00 inc GST

~Christmas Special~ X-mas mince pie

$3.50 – $40.00 inc GST

Canape Pie

Canape Beef and Mushroom, 10 pack

Chunky Cape Grim beef slow cooked with onion, celery, garlic, thyme, black pepper and button mushrooms in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$30.00 inc GST

Canape Classic Beef Mince, 10 pack

Cape Grim beef mince with onion, thyme, garlic and tomato paste cooked in our own free range chicken stock in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$30.00 inc GST

Canape Beef Jalapeno and Cheddar, 10 pack

Our classic beef mince pie topped with a spicy jalapeno cheese sauce in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$30.00 inc GST

Canape Chicken Leek and Mustard, 10 pack

Poached Free Range chicken with sauteed leeks, celery and onion, fresh parsley and wholegrain mustard in a shortcrust base with a puff pastry top.

$30.00 inc GST

Canape Lamb Shepherds, 10 pack

Lamb mince, white wine and rosemary with carrot, onion, peas and Worcestershire sauce in a shortcrust base topped with buttery potato puree.

$30.00 inc GST

Canape Mushroom Bolognese and Cashew Cheese (vegan), 10 pack

Two types of mushrooms with Australian lentils in a traditional bolognese style sauce topped with our own cashew cheese sauce in a vegan shortcrust pastry.

$30.00 inc GST

Canape Pumpkin Lentil Harissa (vegan), 10 pack

Red capsicum with tomato, Australian lentils and our own harissa spice blend finished with roasted butternut pumpkin and coriander in a vegan short pastry.

$30.00 inc GST